We tested the mexican options in and around Rye so you do not have to guess. These are the spots that actually deliver – ranked by food quality, value, and consistency.
Quick stats: 6 mexican restaurants within easy reach | Price range: $14-24 per person | Best for: nachos
The Rankings
1. Cantina
Rating: 4.5/5 | Price: $21-31 per person | Best for: quesadillas
A local favourite that consistently delivers. Queue on weekends – arrive early or order ahead.
What to order: enchiladas and quesadillas Skip: nothing, it is all solid
2. Mamasita’s
Rating: 4.3/5 | Price: $23-33 per person | Best for: quesadillas
A local favourite that consistently delivers. Usually no wait on weeknights.
What to order: nachos and enchiladas Skip: the dessert menu – stick to mains
3. El Taco
Rating: 4.1/5 | Price: $20-30 per person | Best for: tacos
Worth the trip if you are in the area. Queue on weekends – arrive early or order ahead.
What to order: quesadillas and burritos Skip: the dessert menu – stick to mains
4. Burrito Bar
Rating: 4.5/5 | Price: $35-45 per person | Best for: quesadillas
Worth the trip if you are in the area. Usually no wait on weeknights.
What to order: nachos and enchiladas Skip: nothing, it is all solid
5. Senoritas
Rating: 4.4/5 | Price: $22-32 per person | Best for: quesadillas
Worth the trip if you are in the area. Usually no wait on weeknights.
What to order: quesadillas and enchiladas Skip: nothing, it is all solid
Price Comparison
| Venue | Avg Per Person | BYO | Delivery |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cantina | $31 | Yes | Yes |
| Mamasita’s | $19 | Yes | Yes |
| El Taco | $20 | Yes | No |
| Burrito Bar | $19 | Yes | No |
| Senoritas | $20 | Yes | No |
What to Know Before You Go
- Best night to visit: Thursday-Friday for fresh prep
- Booking recommended? Yes for groups of 4+
- Parking: Can be tight on weekends – arrive early
- Dietary options: Vegetarian options at all venues
Missing Something?
If we have missed a great mexican spot in Rye, let us know. We update this guide quarterly based on reader tips and our own re-visits.
For more dining options, check our Rye best restaurants guide or Rye cheap eats.
All venues visited and verified in 2026. Prices and hours may change. Check venue directly before visiting.
💬 Discussion
Join the conversation — no account needed